Ratings & Reviews - Mamma Mia Trattoria

Get an opinion about this business!

Think your friends might be familiar with this merchant? Ask your friends on Facebook to see what they think.

How would you rate this business?
  • Atmosphere: 3.6/5
  • Food: 3.6/5
  • Service: 3.5/5
Sort by:
Language:
Nisha G
By

if you are lookin...

if you are looking for terrible service and looking to be treated like your of no Value I highly recommend this place...

Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

Just ok

Was ok but i wasnt too crazy about it. Was freezing in there too and food seemed a little too oily. friendly staff and service.

Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

Awesome Italian Food

I came in with some friends on a Wednesday night and took advantage of an amazing deal called their Dinner and a Movie night...my husband and I each had an app, main and a dessert plus movie passes and popcorn and drink vouchers all for $69.95. We are movie goers, so I realized what a great deal this was especially when the food is this outstanding. I had a pizza and my husband had a pasta as our mains and you can tell the food was good quality and freshly made to order, not like the crap you get at the chains. We'll be making this our date night restaurant now. Amazing!!!

Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

This was a miss. My wife's pork chop came luke warm, stringy and slightly tough. I ordered the pizza. Again it was luke warm and the best I could describe in taste - benign. Don't order the pizza or bring a McCain's frozen pizza with you and ask them to warm it up or go next door to chucky cheese They had an excellent wine though for the price range. The other guest's dinners (pasta) were again benign at best in taste.

Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

My new favorite place

Had an amazing night out with some friends, ordered from the savour York region "special menu". Let me tell you WOW. The service was great, the food was so enjoyable, full of flavor. You can totally tell that they use fresh ingredient. Our whole table felt the same about our experience. It was my first time at mamma Mia's, and I will definiatly be coming back. I must tell everyone I know. This is a true gem.

Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

Best valentines experience

My husband took me out to celebrate Valentine's day at this charming local restaurant. This place is soooo cute and was decorated for the occasion with candle light, sparkly hearts, rose petals and even lovers' question cards at the tables for a bit of fun. The food was amazing!!!! You can tell everything is made fresh to order and with attention to detail. Although it was a very busy night, our server gave fantastic service and we never felt rushed. I still dream about that tira misu!

Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

It was okay...

We've been to Mamma Mia's a few times over the years. We decided to go back last weekend with friends, as we'd never been to the "new" location. I hated it. It's bigger, but I prefer the old one. The kitchen was LOUD. Which didn't make any sense to me since the old location wasn't, and it had an open kitchen! The food is always up and down, and this time it wasn't up. Since the food is most important to me, I don't think I will be going back.

Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

what a night

it was a friday night the place was packed, we had some wine to start off the night, everything was great the servers were friendly and the chef's were at their prime, i had oredered the veal marsala with side order of chef's pasta, the veal was so tender it melt in my mouth, while my husband ordered the lasagna and our 2 friends ordered the linguini pescatore, the protion sizes were huge we had to take alot of it home, not to mention the homemade tiramisu at the end of the night was just the way to top off the a fabulous evening, we will defintly make our way back there very soon.

Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

I used to come to this restaurant a lot when it was across the street! I find that since they've moved locations the quality of the food in comparison to what it was has really gone down hill.... My server was so moody and my food was super undercooked, honestly this place is unpredictable sometimes it's great sometimes like tonight it's horrible!

Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

We went to Mamma Mia for a late Valentine's Day dinner. Some friends of ours who also live in Newmarket recommended this restaurant. It was about half full, which I thought was good for a Tuesday night. The food was really good despite some of the reviews posted on this site. I found it to be much more authentic than the popular chain-style Italian eatery just down the road. The service was pretty good. We definitely plan to go back and try their pizzas as well as some of their other pasta dishes and desserts.

Atmosphere: 4/5
Food: 4/5
Service: 4/5
Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

I love Mamma Mia, it's probably one of the best...

I love Mamma Mia, it's probably one of the best restaurants that Newmarket/Aurora has to offer at the moment. if you want to get away from the regular chain restaurants, defiently try them. My boyfriend and I go there all the time and the new locations is even better. Both of us are from Italian backgrounds and we love the food. It tastes great and is presented wonderfully. The service is great and the wine is decently priced unlike many other restaurants. we always leave satisfied.

Atmosphere: 4/5
Food: 4/5
Service: 4/5
Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

We came in to see the newly renovated...

We came in to see the newly renovated location(formerly Al.Gonquin's) on Wed. April 8th and wow, what an amazing transformation! I would recommend that the main dining area be made a bit more cozy: it feels really wide open, especially when there aren't a lot of diners. I am certain the ambiance and decor will evolve over time. The bar area looked gorgeous! We ordered Chicken Parmigiana and Chicken Piccata, with grilled calamari as an appetizer. The first chicken was ok, but the Piccata was amazing! So juicy and tasty! Our service was friendly and enthusiastic.

Atmosphere: 3/5
Food: 4/5
Service: 4/5
Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

Great Pasta

We eat here regularly. The food has been excellent on all but one occasion (too much raw garlic – which they rectified satisfactorily). I have never seen any evidence of bread recycling (thankfully) – the bread is almost always cut at the bread station, while we watch. It’s fresh & nice with the oil & balsamic. The pasta is always cooked perfectly, and the sauces are very well done. We always sit in the section of our favorite waitress (Yvonne) who is very good; we have had less satisfying service from others. The only complaint would be that the martinis come in Jr. size. On the upside, the tiramisu is just bloody fantastic! The best I’ve had.

Atmosphere: 5/5
Food: 5/5
Service: 5/5
Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

We had a reservation for 7 P.M. We arrived at...

We had a reservation for 7 P.M. We arrived at 6:55 with one couple arriving just in front of us. There were only two tables free, both near the entrance, one a table for 4 with a reservation sign on it and beside it a table for two. The couple was taken to the table for four and seated. The reservation sign was removed. When we stated we had a reservation for 4, we were told it would be a ten minute wait. Clearly, our table had been given away and the four of us couldn't be seated at the table for two. Once seated, the service was friendly and the food, excellent.

Atmosphere: 2/5
Food: 4/5
Service: 3/5
Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

I enjoyed my meal, it was tasty, but not the best...

I enjoyed my meal, it was tasty, but not the best meal I have ever had in my life. The salmon was great though from the little bit I had (It was my gf meal) Nice waitress, but I thought that she could have been better. Maybe a bit quicker, but she did have a lot of tables to do.

Atmosphere: 4/5
Food: 4/5
Service: 4/5
Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

Been here numerous times, food is consistently...

Been here numerous times, food is consistently good, find the menu dishes better than specials. Atmosphere is cozy, prices are very good, quality is high, service is comfortable.

Atmosphere: 4/5
Food: 5/5
Service: 4/5
Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

server could not be bothered it seemed, I also...

server could not be bothered it seemed, I also saw server reuse bread from another table which made me think if they have the nerve to do that in front of us what else are they doing, seafood was tough. chef boyardee could have done just as good of a job

Atmosphere: 1/5
Food: 1/5
Service: 1/5
Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

I'm Italian and I'm also in the Industry, and the...

I'm Italian and I'm also in the Industry, and the food was a disgrace, risotto was under cooked, veal was over cooked, the place looks like an Italian garage sale, and service... I could get better service in a gas station bathroom. Management was arrogant.

Atmosphere: 1/5
Food: 1/5
Service: 2/5
Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

I thought this restaurant was fantastic, and I am...

I thought this restaurant was fantastic, and I am Italian. I recommend the goat cheese, Five Cheese Agnelotti and Fusilli Alla Vodka and grouper, although everything we ordered was great. Everyone was friendly there, including the bartender and the main host. I have no complaints and the people that are complaining are ridiculous. This is a great restaurant with an amazing atmosphere that makes you feel like you are in a small restaurant in Europe. I was very impressed and cannot wait to return.

Atmosphere: 5/5
Food: 5/5
Service: 5/5
Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Restaurantica12
By

Mamma Mia is a great restaurant that I go to all...

Mamma Mia is a great restaurant that I go to all the time. The Food is very good! The owners, Mark and Adam, are very friendly..very comfortable environment. MMMMMM and the tiramisu is to die for!!!

Atmosphere: 5/5
Food: 5/5
Service: 5/5
Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
Contact this merchant
Close menu
Subscribe to YP Newsletter