Add a photo
4/5
Rate this business
New Looking for instant booking?
You can now reserve online!
1 Old Mill Dr, Toronto, ON M6S 0A1
Get directions »
open now 12:00 pm - 10:00 pm

Methods of Payment:

  • Cash
  • Visa
  • Mastercard
  • Interac
Goodfellas Wood Oven Pizza is a moderately priced casual Italian restaurant. Goodfellas specializes in Italian cuisine and features casual dining, family dining, group functions, and lunch all in a casual atmosphere.

Opening Hours

Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday

Restaurant type

  • Fine Dining,

Cuisine type

  • Italian,

Dishes

  • Pizza,
  • Pasta,

Features

  • Extensive Wine List,
  • Restaurant With Delivery Services,
  • Online Reservation,

Atmosphere

  • Casual,

Languages Spoken

  • English,

Ratings & Reviews - Goodfellas Wood Oven Pizza - Etobicoke

Get an opinion about this business!

Think your friends might be familiar with this merchant? Ask your friends on Facebook to see what they think.

How would you rate this business?
    Sort by:
    Language:
    khog3853
    By

    Food was decent,but a little bland. Food was also overpriced and the prix fixe menu had limited selections and was $20 more than a similar pizza restaurant in the neighbourhood. There is no kids menu even though it is a family friendly area.

    Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
    rose5296
    By

    We have been here 2 times already and the service and food are great. on Saturday we are bringing some friends for their anniversary here, we have bragged so much about this place that they are curious to try it. looking forward to some delicious food.

    Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
    November 15, 2017

    Always experience great service and fantastic meals. Have been there several times and will continue to have special meals there.

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    November 12, 2017

    Love everything about this restaurant and location. Thank you! Rosanna

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    November 12, 2017

    There was some confusion when we arrived with our booking even with the confirmation number. That shouldn't happen with a confirmation of reservation. Secondly the waitresses seem to be confused on which table they were covering.Initially we had 3different waitresses so we didn't know who our waitress was.There was only 4 of us but it was confusing.Also thought the meal was mediocre...2-3stars.We had pizzas.

    Ambiance: 2/5

    Cuisine: 2/5

    Service: 2/5

    November 9, 2017

    A great place

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    November 6, 2017

    No complaints about the food, it was fantastic and so was the service until our waitress brought us our dessert menu and said there was a reservation waiting for our table. Having not even had a chance to look at the menu we felt very rushed and it ruined the end of our night. Perhaps allow the proper time for reservations so this doesn’t happen in future.

    Ambiance: 4/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 4/5

    November 4, 2017

    Amazing as always.

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    November 4, 2017

    Ola was a great ! Patient and polite ! Very happy !

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    October 25, 2017

    We came here for my mother's birthday with a party of 8 - 2 children and 6 adults. We were the only party in the restaurant, but it took 10 minutes before anyone took our drink order. We ordered the arancini for the children to share, calamari for the table and the fresh bread. The arancini and calamari arrived quickly and were very nice, the bread took a very long time (even for fresh baked bread) and it was ages before we were asked to order our mains. 4 people ordered pasta - 2 of the mushroom truffle oil dish, 1 bolognese and 1 of the seafood pasta. All of the spaghetti was over cooked and the sauce on the mushroom pasta was a very unappealing grey colour. The seafood pasta was very skimpy with the seafood for $29. 1 person ordered the veal meatball starter as a main - it was very nice and huge! It should be served with sides as a main, it's a crazy starter. 1 person ordered the fish, which had very good green beans and potatoes on the side, but the fish was just okay and was also overcooked, so it was a bit dry. When the meal was over we all ordered coffees, and we ordered ice cream for the children. The coffee came quite quickly, but three scoops of ice cream took almost 20 minutes. When we asked whether it was coming because we were all ready to go and would just cancel we were told it was "on its way" - after a short wait the ice cream appeared along with a complimentary dessert with a candle in it for my mother, which was a sweet sentiment, but by then we were quite frustrated with the experience and to top it off the free dessert they gave us was disgusting. It is the cannoli siciliani which is described as "cannoli shells filled with fresh ricotta di mucca, rich chocolate hazelnut Nutella and crushed pistachio" - the cannoli shells were rock hard and totally flavourless and the filling was salty and grainy - almost like it had gone sour or off. The chocolate was a measly drizzle that was not enough to cover how gross the actual dessert was and the pistachio was crushed into a stale dust. No joke - it was one of the most dramatic failures of a dessert that I have ever encountered in a restaurant. All in all this place is quite over-priced for the food and the service was pretty poor. I very much doubt we would bother to dine here again.

    Ambiance: 4/5

    Cuisine: 2/5

    Service: 2/5

    October 22, 2017

    You need to turn down the music With a large crowd on Saturday night one had to raise your voice to be heard over the music Restaurants need to tone down the din

    Ambiance: 3/5

    Cuisine: 4/5

    Service: 4/5

    October 17, 2017

    Service was very slow but this was a Sunday night. Hopefully this is not the norm here.

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 4/5

    Service: 2/5

    October 16, 2017

    Our waiter was amazing.

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    October 8, 2017

    We had a great time. Calamari were delicious.. 2 of 3 pizzas were great..the 4 stagioni was a little undercooked. The service was attentive. Will definitely go back. Nice addition to the neighbourhood.

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 4/5

    Service: 5/5

    October 7, 2017

    We were very excited to try Goodfellas but were a bit concerned at a few negative online reviews. I don’t know about the past but I can assure you everything is wonderful now! The decor is tasteful and the staff is warm and welcoming. It was busy when we arrived so the chatter drowned out the music; later on I could hear it and it was good Italian dinner music, including Sinatra. Our server Tom was a consummate professional. I worked in the business for many years so I have high expectations, and I can recognize a pro when I see one: Tom is a pro - in fact the whole serving team showed up with their A game this night. My wife and I really needed to relax and be pampered and we were! The food was excellent: salad and pizzas were fresh and perfectly spiced, presented, and cooked. The house wine was great and tiramisu and gelato very good. I don’t mind paying a little more for a superior experience and Goosfellas delivered. Thank you Tom to the whole staff at Goodfeklas. We will be back!

    Ambiance: 4/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    October 5, 2017

    First visit to the Old Mill location on Wednesday for lunch. Nice decor (Godfather chic as the name suggests), friendly staff and the food was very good. This is not fine Italian dining but for the price it was good. Very few people in the restaurant so I was surprised how long the time was between the meal served and seeing the wait staff for dessert/cheque. Maybe a bit more attentiveness in the future. Overall we will return. Thanks.

    Ambiance: 4/5

    Cuisine: 4/5

    Service: 3/5

    October 5, 2017

    I'm soo pleased with service and atmosphere! Food was delicious 😋, Next time I will definitely go for romantic dinner not only for business! Thank you so much! I'm so trelld

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    September 26, 2017

    very disgusting services, wait staff playing musical tables, had 3 different people serve us, one server asked 15 times if we wanted wine and kept trying to push wine on us even though we repeatedly said no, there was a hair is the $49.00 cheese and meat board that came with only 4 tiny slices of break and slim pickings of meat and cheese and we were in a group of 6. we asked for more bread and they insisted on charging us extra. there was no air conditioning on in the restaurant it was sweltering heat hottest day this year so we decided to sit out side upon making that decisions they closed the doors and turned the a/c on. very dissatisfied and they just lost 6 customers because of it

    Ambiance: 1/5

    Cuisine: 1/5

    Service: 1/5

    September 25, 2017

    Amazing food !

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    September 26, 2017

    Great place...food and service were great. TheFrittura Mista seafood platter is amazing. We will definitely go back.

    Ambiance: 4/5

    Cuisine: 4/5

    Service: 4/5

    September 25, 2017

    Great food and ambience. Need to get air conditioning! I realize it was one of the hottest weekends , but no fan or air conditioning is tough to endure ! Especially for elderly Otherwise great tasting menu !

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    September 18, 2017

    Will be back more often. Start with the calamari appetizers, yummy and feel yourselves in the upscale restaurant with the elegant food.

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    September 18, 2017

    I celebrated by Birthday there! Invited 13 people and ordered party pizzas and brought my own cake with balloons. The personnel was treating my guests and myself on a very high level. Truly enjoyed my time there. Felt like I was in Italy in a very sophisticated restaurant. Five stars!

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    September 18, 2017

    Keep coming back!!

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 4/5

    September 16, 2017

    We enjoyed the food and the place is really nice.

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    September 10, 2017

    Food took a very long time to be served on our table.

    Ambiance: 4/5

    Cuisine: 4/5

    Service: 4/5

    September 8, 2017

    We had a wonderful experience food was amazing!!!

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    August 29, 2017

    Quality/and quantity of the food for what you pay in a wonderful Italian atmosphere is very reasonable.

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 4/5

    August 23, 2017

    Great as usual

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    August 20, 2017

    Pasta portion was small compared to similar restaurants. Also a bit pricey for the value.

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 4/5

    Service: 5/5

    August 17, 2017

    We were very disappointed with the food. Three of us ordered Sea Bass and it was barely edible. I won't go back!

    Ambiance: 3/5

    Cuisine: 1/5

    Service: 3/5

    August 14, 2017

    I had been so looking forward to trying this new restauraurant in my neighbourhood for quite a while. I suggested it to some friends, who also had been looking forward to having a meal there. Every time I drive by the restaurant, there are many customers and it always looks so friendly and inviting. There were four of us and we each ordered a pizza, and shared a salad and the bruschetta to start. The salad suggested pistachios as an added garnish. It was pistachio powder. With the bruschetta came a small shot glass of Chili oil. The pizzas were thin, very crisp, with a very generous lip of dry crust. I asked the waiter, who was very personable, for some olive oil to douse the pizza with. He came back with a small shot glass of olive oil for presumably the four of us to share. Needless to say, everyone only ate the centre portion of their pizzas, which was very disappointing. The fixed price menu also did not make any sense, as you could order some individual items for much less. Great location, nicely appointed, nice staff, but unfortunately we will never be returning.

    Ambiance: 4/5

    Cuisine: 1/5

    Service: 3/5

    Contact this merchant
    Close menu
    Subscribe to YP Newsletter