Add a photo
4/5
Rate this business
New Looking for instant booking?
You can now reserve online!
1 Old Mill Dr, Toronto, ON M6S 0A1
Get directions »
Closed now 11:30 am - 10:30 pm

Methods of Payment:

  • Cash
  • Visa
  • Mastercard
  • Interac

Opening Hours

Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday

Restaurant type

  • Fine Dining,

Cuisine type

  • Italian,

Dishes

  • Pizza,
  • Pasta,
  • Meat And Cheese,
  • Veggie Platters,

Features

  • Extensive Wine List,
  • Restaurant With Delivery Services,
  • Online Reservation,

Atmosphere

  • Casual,

Languages Spoken

  • English,

Ratings & Reviews - Goodfellas Wood Oven Pizza - Etobicoke

How would you rate this business?
    Sort by:
    Language:
    khog3853
    By

    Food was decent,but a little bland. Food was also overpriced and the prix fixe menu had limited selections and was $20 more than a similar pizza restaurant in the neighbourhood. There is no kids menu even though it is a family friendly area.

    Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
    rose5296
    By

    We have been here 2 times already and the service and food are great. on Saturday we are bringing some friends for their anniversary here, we have bragged so much about this place that they are curious to try it. looking forward to some delicious food.

    Are you the owner? Reply or Contact YP
    June 16, 2018

    Terrible. We had 2 small children and people that came later were served before us. When the food finalky cane it was cold.

    Ambiance: 1/5

    Cuisine: 1/5

    Service: 1/5

    June 12, 2018

    All in our group of 7 enjoyed the dinner experience & we will definitely return. Excellent meal & service.

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    May 28, 2018

    Our server was very attentive without being obtrusive. The food was excellent and served in a timely manner. This was our second visit and we will definitely be returning.

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    May 27, 2018

    Excellent all arpund!

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    May 18, 2018

    It was a lovely evening to dine on your pizzas with my daughter! We both loved it!

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    May 15, 2018

    The food is delicious - one of my favourite restaurants.

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    May 10, 2018

    Our server was excellent and so was the food. But it was very slow in coming!

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 4/5

    May 6, 2018

    Hoping for better, but just average. ***/*****

    Ambiance: 4/5

    Cuisine: 3/5

    Service: 4/5

    April 29, 2018

    What a gem this place is! First off, gorgeous looking - very clean and has that Italian flare. The servers are excellent and go that extra step! We we're there for a birthday and had a bouquet of flowers. They rigged up a vase for us to display our flowers and keep them in water. The servers are a delight and have a playful attitude. The food is excellent - best pizza I've had in Toronto.. but the staff there makes this place special. Highly recommend!! You won't be disappointed and your photos will look amazing in this place! Can't wait to have an excuse to go back again with another party! PS if you get Lorenza at your table, your experience is kicked up even further!

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    April 30, 2018

    The atmosphere was pleasant and the service was good but the food was not good enough to bring us back.

    Ambiance: 4/5

    Cuisine: 2/5

    Service: 4/5

    April 22, 2018

    Had to send my food back twice was served wrong salad and fish was way under cooked and I had asked for it to be well done. Won’t be going back.

    Ambiance: 3/5

    Cuisine: 1/5

    Service: 4/5

    April 22, 2018

    The atmosphere, service and food were very good.

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    April 21, 2018

    Very nice atmosphere. Two of the six dishes were cold/undercooked. So sign of our server after the food was served. Two of the meals were great and the remaining two were fairly plain. Believe for the price the service should be better and food served hot. In fairness, after the meal was over the waiter provided another complimentary dinner which was very nice, however a trip back to the table before the end of the meal would have prevented having to do this. Overall adequate - don’t think we will rush back.

    Ambiance: 4/5

    Cuisine: 2/5

    Service: 3/5

    April 17, 2018

    Did not enjoy the lamb shank, bland the fake out of the box mashed potatoes were like wallpaper paste I’m sure the wallpaper paste would taste better in my opinion. Definitely will not be back. This was supposed to be a special anniversary diner. BIG Mistake!!!

    Ambiance: 3/5

    Cuisine: 1/5

    Service: 3/5

    March 31, 2018

    Everything excellent. Had a great evening.

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    March 20, 2018

    I have been here before. I had bolognese pasta. It was ok. At one point there was a singer in restaurant and my date and I left as we could not hear each other talk.

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 1/5

    Service: 4/5

    March 10, 2018

    After a long wait for our food (seems like the server forgot about us after the order) another member of staff brought us our pizzas which were cold! Very disappointing we could see our server hanging out chatting to another member of staff in the bar area so had to again call another member of staff who said they would let him know. We sat for 15 mins more before I had to leave my seat to ask for the bill just to get out of there. The worst service I’ve had iin Toronto. Avoid here like the plague!

    Ambiance: 1/5

    Cuisine: 1/5

    Service: 1/5

    March 4, 2018

    Keep going back. Food always excellent!

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    March 4, 2018

    Superb food. Very noisey on a Saturday nite,

    Ambiance: 3/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    March 1, 2018

    We had a large party and the staff at Goodfellas were professional, pleasant and service was smooth and fast. We had a great time thanks to the hospitality of Goodfellas!!

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    February 26, 2018

    Great service. A wonderful restaurant and all-round fabulous experience.

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 4/5

    Service: 5/5

    February 26, 2018

    Our waiter gave us some great recommendations and made our evening enjoyable.

    Ambiance: 4/5

    Cuisine: 4/5

    Service: 5/5

    February 23, 2018

    We had great experience! The staff were all very attentive and pleasant. The food was all wonderful ...served quickly, beautifully presented, all very fresh and deliously as you’d hope it to be. Thank you for a lovely experience!

    Ambiance: 4/5

    Cuisine: 4/5

    Service: 5/5

    February 20, 2018

    Excellent service, restaurant is well arranged to allow for privacy or accessibility, food is delicious

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 4/5

    Service: 5/5

    February 20, 2018

    Wonderful family dinner at Good Fellas for Family Day. Service was attentive without being overly so. Had the Arancini appetizer (we shared ... it’s big). Very tasty. 3 of us had pizza and it was awesome. One ordered the chicken Parm which was tasty but had to be sent back as it wasn’t warm in the centre. Comes with a salad but you can change to pasta for $5... seems a bit excessive overcharge for that switch to a very small bowl of pasta. They comped a dessert for the aggravation of sending back the chicken which was nice. We enjoyed the red wine with dinner. Seems they have taken some hints and are keeping their red wines at a better temp now (used to be too warm). Overall, very good family dinner.

    Ambiance: 4/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    February 15, 2018

    Valentines experience was wonderful

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    February 3, 2018

    Exceptionally good pizza, salads, desserts and wine selections with outstanding service and an old world rustic interior. Located conveniently close to easy parking and Jane subway station, the location is excellent too. The Old Mill neighbourhood is most fortunate to have Goodfellas. Russell Sergiades

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    January 28, 2018

    My husband and I celebrated our 3rd wedding anniversary. Food was ok. My husband's entree, the mixed grilled seafood platter that comes with a salad was nicely prepared however when he takes a third or fourth bite of his salad he found what looked like a half sized prune. We both investigate it and he takes it apart and tastes it and it was dirt (soil). We immediately called our server and asked her what it was, as we were still confused and unsure. She takes the plate and returns minutes later saying the manager will come speak with us and they think it was the charred part of the grill. We told her that it was inside the salad and it tasted like dirt and it wasn't hard and crispy like charred pieces but it was soft. She leaves and comes back again saying the manager was just in the middle of something and will come to our table. As we were waiting my husband was trying to get the taste out of his mouth and was pretty much turned off from food. She comes back and asks my husband if he wants tea or coffee he says "no" but I asked her if he was still going to get some of his food back as it still had quite a bit of seafood left. She asks him but he said "no, thanks" because he was no longer in the mood to eat. She says the manager will come to our table shortly and she leaves again. The server comes back again and says that his entree was taken care of. The manager never came to our table. We were quite upset that the manager didn't bother coming to our table to speak with us. We believe our whole meal should have been taken care of. The evening, our wedding anniversary date, didn't turn out the way we wanted to.

    Ambiance: 4/5

    Cuisine: 1/5

    Service: 3/5

    January 28, 2018

    Waiter rushed us. Food expensive for what you get.

    Ambiance: 4/5

    Cuisine: 2/5

    Service: 3/5

    January 28, 2018

    We love it here!

    Ambiance: 5/5

    Cuisine: 5/5

    Service: 5/5

    Get an opinion about this business!

    Think your friends might be familiar with this business? Ask your friends on Facebook to see what they think.

    Contact this business
    Close menu
    Subscribe to YP Newsletter